Objects
Girl Guide War Service badges, First World War
Two War Service badges in the Norfolk archive, catalogued as 1914 and 1918, and a puzzle about which one is the original.

The Norfolk archive holds two Girl Guide War Service badges, catalogued as 1914 and 1918. Its own caption asks: “Which is a replica and which is original? How do you know?”[1][2]

Both badges are red cloth with a gold embroidered crown and a year.
What the badge required
According to an enthusiast history, the War Service Badge was introduced in May 1915. A Guide could earn it in one of three ways: “Not fewer than 21 days’ special service” for hospitals and similar bodies, for at least three hours a day; “Not fewer than 15 articles personally made”, including socks, mittens, shirts and a pyjama suit; or 21 days’ paid work for firms working for the Government in connection with the war.[4] The Norfolk archive summarises the syllabus a little differently (21 days of voluntary war service, 100 hours of agricultural work, or 15 garments) and says that “Separate dated badges were issued for each year”.[5] Evidence status: Unconfirmed Neither source names the rules edition it draws on, and they differ on the work option (paid war work or agricultural work), so the exact syllabus is not yet confirmed.
Original or replica?
Evidence status: Disputed The archive does not say which badge is which, so the dates and the status of both badges are in doubt. It is also unclear whether “1914” is the year the badge was made or the year the war began. Two secondary histories date the introduction of the War Service Badge to 1915,[3][4] which would make a badge made in 1914 unlikely. That date is not yet confirmed from a primary source either.
In the photographs, the badge catalogued as 1914 has crisp, even machine embroidery and neatly finished edges, while the 1918 badge is raised, uneven and frayed. That is our own observation from the images, not the archive’s verdict, and it cannot settle the question on its own. Closer examination would look at the cloth and thread, whether the embroidery was done by hand or by machine, the backing, and how the badge was attached to a uniform.
Why it matters
Badges are some of the most collected Guiding objects, and replicas and later reissues are common. An object page that says “1914” can mislead unless it also says how the date was established. This is why we give the evidence for every date.
See also: Guides in the First World War.
Object story
- What is it, who made it, and when?
- Two Girl Guide War Service badges, catalogued by the archive as dating from 1914 and 1918.
- Who owned or used it?
- Not recorded: the archive's online entries do not say who earned or wore either badge.
- What did official rules say?
- A War Service Badge recognised Guides' wartime work. Two secondary histories date its introduction to 1915, one to May 1915, when a Guide could qualify by 21 days' special service, by making 15 listed garments, or by 21 days' paid war work. The Norfolk archive says separate dated badges were issued for each year. None of this is yet confirmed from a rules edition of the time.
- What signs of use, alteration or repair remain?
- Visible in the photographs: the badge catalogued as 1914 is flat and evenly machine-embroidered, with a neat corded edge. The badge catalogued as 1918 has raised, uneven embroidery on a feltlike red cloth, with loose threads at its cut edges. Neither photograph shows the back.
- What larger story can it tell, and what can it not prove?
- The pair raises a basic question for anyone working with Guiding objects: how to tell an original from a later replica.
- Where is it held, what is its accession number, and what are the reuse terms?
- Girlguiding Norfolk Archive Resource Centre, Coltishall. No accession numbers are published. The online images are licensed CC BY-NC-SA 3.0.
Sources
- Girlguiding Norfolk Archive Resource Centre (via MyLearning), “Girl Guide War Service Badge 1914”, MyLearning. Accessed 25 September 2026. Image © Girlguiding Norfolk County Archive Resource Centre, licensed CC BY-NC-SA 3.0.
- Girlguiding Norfolk Archive Resource Centre (via MyLearning), “Girl Guide War Service Badge 1918”, MyLearning. Accessed 25 September 2026. Image © Girlguiding Norfolk County Archive Resource Centre, licensed CC BY-NC-SA 3.0.
- Little Gem Museum (West Lancashire Scouts), “Story of Guiding – 1908 to 1929”, 2022-03-15. Accessed 25 September 2026. A volunteer-run heritage timeline; a useful lead, to be checked against primary sources.
- Leslie's Guide War History, “World War 1”. Accessed 25 September 2026. Enthusiast history; a lead.
- Girlguiding Norfolk Archive Resource Centre (via MyLearning), “Identifying Service: A World of Badges”, Girl Guides: Aspects of a Fascinating History, MyLearning. Accessed 25 October 2026.