Objects
The first Brownie handbook (1920)
The first handbook written for the Brownie section, by Robert Baden-Powell. Sources give its 1920 title in different forms, and no first edition has yet been seen.
The first handbook written for Brownies appeared in 1920, the same year Senior Guides became Rangers.[1] Robert Baden-Powell wrote it, and C. Arthur Pearson published it in London.[5] Girl Guides of Canada says it “was used for many years in Canada as well as the United Kingdom”.[4]
What was it called?
Evidence status: Disputed Sources differ on the title. A 1922 American Girl Scout manual cites the 1920 book as Brownies or Bluebirds: A Handbook for Young Girl Guides, and Girlguiding’s centenary timeline gives almost the same wording.[5][6] An enthusiast history calls it The Handbook for Brownies or Bluebirds, and a 2022 academic chapter cites the seventh edition of 1928 under that title.[2][7] The New York Public Library holds an “Eleventh edition” of about 1936 called The Handbook for Brownies and Blue Birds, 54 pages long, and a 1953 printing called A Handbook for Brownies.[8][9] The title probably changed between editions. Until a 1920 copy is found, the exact first title is not confirmed.[3]
“Bluebirds” was offered as another name for countries where the Brownie name and story would not suit.[2]
What it contained
We have not seen the 1920 text, but two kinds of evidence give a partial picture.
The first is a quotation. The 1922 American manual reprints two games “taken from” the 1920 handbook, pages 51 to 55, so the first edition had at least 55 pages. In one, “The Brown Owl stands in the middle of the room” while the points of the compass are chalked on the floor; the SixA small group within a Brownie unit, led by a Sixer with a Second as deputy. Six names traditionally drew on folklore, with gnomes, pixies, elves, imps, sprites and kelpies among them. Animal names are said to have been added in the 2000s, but that date is not yet confirmed. whose members are first out wins. The other teaches the reef knot and the bowline by letting Brownies work out what each knot is for.[5]
The second is later text by the same author. Girlguiding’s timeline dates the Brownie LawA short set of principles members agree to follow. The original had ten clauses; it has been revised several times. to 1920.[6] By 1941, Baden-Powell’s Girl Guiding had a part for Brownies. It opens with “The Story of the Brownies”, “Adapted from The Brownies, by Mrs. Ewing”: two untidy children, Tommy and Betty, ask a wise brown owl how to find a Brownie to help at home, and learn that they can be the Brownies themselves. It goes on to the toadstool, the Fairy Ring, the uniform, the Sixes and their rhymes, and the PromiseThe commitment members are invited to make when they feel ready. Its wording varies by country and changed twelve times in the UK between 1910 and 2013, notably in 1994 and 2013.: to do one’s duty to God and the King, and to help other people every day, especially those at home.[11] Evidence status: Unconfirmed We have not yet confirmed that these passages repeat the 1920 handbook. An enthusiast history says the Ewing story “appeared in the handbooks for many years”, which suggests they may.[2]
A reader abroad
The American editors of 1922 borrowed from the book but did not copy its scheme. They noted that “The English system provides no minimum age for Brownies”, which they thought impractical, and found fairy names for groups “somewhat artificial”.[5]
Evidence status: Interpretation A handbook prescribes. This one shows what adults hoped Brownies would be: helpful at home and loyal to their Brown Owl and their Six. It cannot tell us how packs used it. The Internet Archive’s 1957 printing, for borrowing only, would allow later editions to be compared.[10]
Object story
- What is it, who made it, and when?
- A handbook for the Brownie section by Sir Robert Baden-Powell, published in London by C. Arthur Pearson in 1920. A 1922 American manual cites it as Brownies or Bluebirds: A Handbook for Young Girl Guides. Later editions appear as The Handbook for Brownies or Bluebirds (seventh edition, 1928), The Handbook for Brownies and Blue Birds (eleventh edition, about 1936) and A Handbook for Brownies (1950s). No 1920 copy has yet been seen.
- What did official rules say?
- The handbook was itself an official rulebook for Brownies, but we have not seen its 1920 wording. Girlguiding's centenary timeline says the Brownie Law was introduced in 1920: 'The Brownie gives in to older folk, the Brownie does not give in to herself'.
- What larger story can it tell, and what can it not prove?
- It can show how adults imagined the youngest members through folklore, play and helpfulness at home. It cannot show what Brownies actually did.
- Where is it held, what is its accession number, and what are the reuse terms?
- No 1920 copy located yet. The New York Public Library holds the eleventh edition (about 1936, shelfmark SHD p.v. 132) and a 1953 printing (SB p.v. 3012). The Internet Archive has a 1957 printing for borrowing only. We could not search the British Library or National Library of Scotland catalogues online for this check.
Still open: Who owned or used it? · What signs of use, alteration or repair remain? If you can answer any of these, please tell us.
Sources
- Girlguiding North West England, “Guiding history (blog post 1)”, 2023-09. Accessed 25 September 2026. Regional summary; use as a lead and check against rules editions.
- Leslie's Guiding History, “Brownies”. Accessed 25 September 2026. Enthusiast history; a lead.
- Sir Robert Baden-Powell, “Brownies or Bluebirds: A Handbook for Young Girl Guides”, C. Arthur Pearson, 1920. details to check Title as cited in a 1922 American Girl Scout manual. Later sources give "The Handbook for Brownies or Bluebirds", and later editions were titled A Handbook for Brownies. First edition not yet seen.
- Girl Guides of Canada–Guides du Canada, “History of Guiding (fact sheet 14.3.1.3)”, Girl Guides of Canada. Accessed 25 September 2026. Another national organisation's own history; useful for early dates, not an independent evaluation.
- Girl Scouts (United States), “The Brownie Book: A Manual for Leaders of Junior Girl Scouts. Advance proof for experiment and use in the field, March, 1922”, Girl Scouts, Incorporated, New York, 1922. Accessed 25 October 2026. (pp. 4, 50–52)Library of Congress copy, digitised on the Internet Archive; the Library of Congress is 'unaware of any copyright restrictions'. Page 50 quotes two games 'taken from' the 1920 British Brownie handbook and gives its title, publisher and pages.
- Girlguiding, “Brownies Timeline: Important events through Brownies 100 year history”, Girlguiding Brownies centenary blog, 2014. Accessed 25 September 2026. details to check Centenary blog; use as a lead and confirm against the Girl Guides' Gazette.
- Catherine Bannister, “Brownies' Stories: Storytelling, Legend and Locality as Markers of Group Membership”, Scouting and Guiding in Britain, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham, 2022, pp. 169–188. Accessed 25 October 2026. We have read only the publisher's abstract and reference list, which cites the seventh edition (1928) of the Brownie handbook.
- New York Public Library, “The handbook for Brownies and Blue Birds, by Lord Baden-Powell (catalogue record)”, New York Public Library Research Catalog. Accessed 25 October 2026. London: C. A. Pearson, [1936]. 'Eleventh edition.' 54 pages, illustrated, 19 cm. Shelfmark SHD p.v. 132. OCLC 42388137.
- New York Public Library, “A handbook for Brownies (catalogue record)”, New York Public Library Research Catalog. Accessed 25 October 2026. C. A. Pearson, 1953. 62 pages, illustrated, 19 cm. 'Previous ed. 1952.' Shelfmark SB p.v. 3012.
- Internet Archive, “A handbook for Brownies (1957 printing; item handbookforbrown0000lord)”. Accessed 25 October 2026. Scanned in 2022 for the Internet Archive's lending library; borrowing only, not open access. We have read only the item's metadata.
- Lord Baden-Powell of Gilwell, “Girl Guiding: A Handbook for Brownies, Guides, Rangers, and Guiders (fourteenth edition)”, C. Arthur Pearson, 1941. Accessed 25 October 2026. (pp. 11–21)First published February 1918. We read the fourteenth edition (1941) in a digitised copy; the foreword and explanation are signed "Founder" and are not dated, so they may differ from the 1918 text. Publisher's name read from an imperfect scan.