On Saturday 4 September 1909 Scouts gathered for a rally at Crystal Palace in London: about 11,000 of them, according to a volunteer-run heritage timeline, though we have not yet checked that figure against reports of the time.[4] Among them were girls who presented themselves as Girl Scouts. WAGGGS dates the decisive rally to that year: the girls, it says, “prompted the founder to include girls”.[1]

How many girls?

Accounts differ widely. Girlguiding describes “a small handful of girls”.[2] The geographer Sarah Mills gives “several hundred”.[3] Evidence status: Disputed The number is genuinely in doubt: we have not yet found a count made at the time, and the two figures cannot both be right.

How the story is told

Girlguiding’s history says the girls “gatecrashed” the rally, demanding “something for the girls”.[2] It is a good story, and it puts girls’ own initiative at the centre. Not every organisation tells it that way: the Canadian account speaks only of “great astonishment” at a group at the end of the parade.[5]

The dramatic language may also hide something: girls’ patrols already existed and were not a sudden intrusion. Evidence status: Unconfirmed Later accounts say that several of the girls there, Marguerite de Beaumont among them, were already in patrols. There is doubt about this: those accounts were written long afterwards, and we have not yet confirmed them from sources of the time.

Evidence status: Interpretation The rally is better understood as the point at which girls’ Scouting became too visible for adult organisers to ignore. That visibility forced a question (should girls do the same things as boys?) that the movement would keep answering differently for more than a century.

What we are checking

  • Contemporary reports of the rally, rather than later retellings.
  • Whether any girls’ names, units or photographs can be identified from sources of the time.
  • When the word “gatecrash” first appears in official histories.

People and objects

  • 22 February 1857 – 8 January 1941

    Robert Baden-Powell

    Army officer and founder of Scouting, who set out the girls' scheme with his sister Agnes, wrote Guiding's handbooks from 1918 and signed them as "Founder".

Sources

  1. World Association of Girl Guides and Girl Scouts, “Our history”, WAGGGS. Accessed 25 September 2026. (timeline, 1909)
  2. Girlguiding, “Our history”. Accessed 25 September 2026. Institutional self-description. Authoritative for what Girlguiding says about itself; not an independent evaluation.
  3. Sarah Mills, “Scouting for girls? Gender and the Scout Movement in Britain”, Gender, Place & Culture 18, no. 4, 2011, pp. 537–556.
  4. Little Gem Museum (West Lancashire Scouts), “Story of Guiding – 1908 to 1929”, 2022-03-15. Accessed 25 September 2026. A volunteer-run heritage timeline; a useful lead, to be checked against primary sources.
  5. Girl Guides of Canada–Guides du Canada, “History of Guiding (fact sheet 14.3.1.3)”, Girl Guides of Canada. Accessed 25 September 2026. Another national organisation's own history; useful for early dates, not an independent evaluation.

About this page

Status
Awaiting fact-check · confidence: confirmed
Written by
Claire Mcdonald
Reviewed by
Awaiting external review
Last updated
25 September 2026

Spotted an error or have evidence to add? Tell us how to correct this page.