A new Promise without "God"
After a consultation with about 44,000 responses, the UK Promise replaced "to love my God" with "to be true to myself and develop my beliefs", and "my country" with "my community".
Girlguiding consulted on its Promise from 4 January to 3 March 2013, and about 44,000 people gave their views. The new wording was announced in June 2013 and took effect on 1 September 2013.[1][2]
Two things changed. “To love my God” was replaced with “to be true to myself and develop my beliefs”. And “to serve the Queen and my country” became “to serve the Queen and my community”. The Rainbow Promise became “to think about my beliefs and to be kind and helpful”.[1]
Responses
Supporters saw a Promise that any girl could make honestly. Critics, including some faith-based members and organisations such as the Evangelical Alliance, felt that something central had been lost.[2] In February 2014, after a unit in Newcastle refused to use the new wording, Girlguiding allowed members to state their own belief before making the Promise if they wished.[3]
Evidence status: Interpretation It is too simple to describe this as religion versus secularism. “Develop my beliefs” can be read as a spiritual commitment, and faith-based members and humanists have interpreted it in different ways.
Part of a longer history
Girlguiding counts this as the twelfth change to the Promise since the movement began.[1] See the full history of the Promise and Law.
Sources
- Girlguiding, “Background and concepts of the Promise and Law for trainers”, The Guide Association, 2013. Accessed 25 September 2026.
- ITV News, “Girl Guides drop God vow from Promise”, 2013-06-19. Accessed 25 September 2026.
- National Secular Society, “Girlguides offer concessions over Promise following religious pressure”, 2014-02. A campaigning organisation; its framing is its own.