A movement for girls

Guiding began as a movement for girls, separate from the Scouts. That separation has lasted, even as Scouting changed. Venture Scouts admitted girls from 1976; all Scout groups have had to accept girls since 2007.[8] Girlguiding remains a single-sex organisation, and what “girl” means for membership has become one of the most contested questions in its history.

Disabled girls

For much of the twentieth century, disabled and chronically ill girls were provided for through what was called Extension Guiding. This included units in hospitals and residential homes, and, according to enthusiasts’ histories that we have not yet confirmed, units for housebound girls that met by letter. Grace Chapman’s research on Scouting and Guiding in the north of England, 1907–1970, is the best study of this provision.[1]

Evidence status: Interpretation Extension Guiding opened Guiding to girls who would otherwise have been left out. It also kept many of them apart from other girls. Period sources use language about disability now regarded as offensive; we quote it only where it is needed to understand the history.

Today Girlguiding’s policy allows reasonable adjustments for disabled members, including flexibility about the upper age of a section.[2]

Race and empire

In the first decade, who could join depended on where you lived. Mary Clare Martin finds that some companies in Africa excluded Black girls, companies in what is now Malaysia were usually ethnically mixed, and India had both segregated and mixed companies.[3] How membership in Britain itself reflected, or excluded, Black and Asian girls, before and after 1945, has hardly been researched, and we cannot yet say.

In September 2020 Girlguiding committed to becoming anti-racist and said it would review its “historic roots”.[4] A 2021 update listed race equity training and a diversity and inclusion plan.[5] What those commitments have changed is not yet clear from published evidence.

Belief

The Promise was rewritten twelve times between 1910 and 2013.[6] In 1994 “do my duty to God” became “to love my God”. In 2013, after a consultation with about 44,000 responses, it became “to be true to myself and develop my beliefs”.[6] Supporters saw a Promise every girl could make honestly; some faith-based members felt something central had been lost. In 2014 Girlguiding allowed members to state their own belief before making the Promise.[7]

Class

Membership cost money: for subscriptions, uniform, camps and travel. Objects such as a Brownie dress altered to match a newer style suggest families making do. But we do not yet have the evidence (household budgets, uniform prices, membership by area) to say how far cost kept girls out. That is one of this site’s research priorities.

Gender identity

In April 2022 Girlguiding settled a legal case brought by a former volunteer. It recognised that gender-critical beliefs are protected under the Equality Act, while stating that it “is also, and shall remain, a home for trans people”.[9]

On 16 April 2025 the UK Supreme Court held, in For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers, that “sex”, “woman” and “man” in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex. The case did not concern Girlguiding.[10] On 2 December 2025 Girlguiding announced that trans girls and young women could no longer join, saying it must operate lawfully and follow its governing documents.[11] In March 2026 it said existing trans girl members would leave by 6 September 2026. For membership it defined “girl” and “woman” by sex at birth. Trans boys, trans men and non-binary people assigned female at birth were not affected.[12]

Groups including the Good Law Project, TransActual and Mermaids criticised the decision; Mermaids said it was “deeply saddened and disappointed”.[13][14] The campaign group Sex Matters welcomed it, according to press reports quoting its chief executive;[15] we have not yet seen its own statement. When Girlguiding first adopted trans-inclusive guidance is uncertain: press reports give both 2017 and 2018.

Evidence status: Interpretation This change is recent and deeply felt on all sides. We report the organisation’s policy from its own words, the law from the judgment, and responses by naming who made them. We will update this section as the record grows.

Read more

Sources

  1. Grace Chapman, 'Handicapped': Boy Scouts, Girl Guides, and the Provision of Youth Movement Activities for Disabled Children in the North of England, 1907–1970, University of Huddersfield (doctoral thesis), 2022.
  2. Girlguiding, “Young members policy”. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  3. Mary Clare Martin, “Race, Indigeneity and the Baden-Powell Girl Guides: Age, Gender and the British World, 1908–1920”, Children, Childhood and Youth in the British World, ed. Shirleene Robinson and Simon Sleight, Palgrave Macmillan, 2016, pp. 161–179.
  4. Girlguiding, “Our ongoing commitment to black lives matter: How we're getting to work”, 2020-09-27. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  5. Amanda Amaeshi (Girlguiding advocate), “We need to keep talking about Black Lives Matter”, Girlguiding, 2021-05-25. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  6. Girlguiding, “Background and concepts of the Promise and Law for trainers”, The Guide Association, 2013. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  7. National Secular Society, “Girlguides offer concessions over Promise following religious pressure”, 2014-02. A campaigning organisation; its framing is its own.
  8. The Scout Association, “The Passing Years: Milestones in the progress of Scouting (factsheet FS295306)”. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  9. Girlguiding, “Girlguiding settlement statement”, 2022-04-19. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  10. UK Supreme Court, “For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers [2025] UKSC 16”, The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, 2025-04-16.
  11. Girlguiding, “Statement for members on our equality and diversity policy”, 2025-12-02. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  12. Girlguiding, “Update following changes to our equality and diversity policy”, 2026-03-24. Accessed 25 September 2026.
  13. Tessa Flemming, “Transgender women will no longer be allowed to join two of the UK's leading groups for women and girls”, ABC News (Australia), 2025-12-04.
  14. Mermaids, “Statement on the exclusion of trans people from Girlguiding and the Women's Institute”, 2025-12-08.
  15. The Christian Institute, “Girlguiding ditches trans-inclusive policy for new members”, 2025-12-04. Accessed 11 November 2026. News report by a campaigning Christian charity. Cited only for its quotation of Sex Matters' chief executive.