Ideas and society
Gender and citizenship
Housework and hiking, discipline and leadership, service and ambition: how Guiding trained girls to be particular kinds of citizens.
Early Guiding neither simply freed girls nor simply confined them. It did both at once, and this page is about how.
Opposites side by side
Look at almost any period of Guiding and you find things that seem to pull in opposite directions:
- domestic training beside outdoor independence;
- discipline beside peer leadership, as girls ran their own patrolsA small group of Guides (today usually four to eight) led by one of the girls themselves. The basic unit of peer leadership in Guiding.;
- service to others beside personal ambition;
- respectable femininity beside practical, physical competence.
Evidence status: Interpretation Historians treat these not as contradictions to be resolved but as the heart of the matter. Tammy Proctor argues that interwar Guiding used “gendered assumptions about citizenship”, training girls as “citizen servants” of the nation through the home: “Scouts sought to mold ideal citizens, while Guides taught the mothers of the future.”[1]
The geographer Sarah Mills describes Guiding as built on “fixed gender roles”. But her study of girls who tried to join the Scouts (in 1908–16 and again in 1975–90) shows them negotiating and pushing against those roles through everyday practices such as dressing, writing and crafting.[2]
Prescription and practice
Handbooks tell us what adults wanted. They do not tell us what girls did. Kristine Alexander argues that Guiding’s structure let some girls adapt it “for their own, sometimes subversive, ends”, and that girls’ responses show a movement that was “both contested and flexible”.[3]
That difference runs through this whole site: we try to put the official ideal beside the lived experience.
Changing girlhoods
The meaning of “citizenship” changed across the century. Penny Tinkler has examined how 1940s writing on girls’ education and leisure framed their citizenship in international terms.[4] Jim Gledhill argues that in the 1960s the Girl Guides Association reinvented itself by absorbing the tastes of British youth, a revival that complicates the picture of the decade as one of youthful radicalism.[5] Amy Halls, Emma Uprichard and Clare Jackson use every edition of the Guide handbook since 1910 to trace how girlhood itself changed.[6]
What we are researching next
- Which activities were genuinely new for girls in their time.
- How the programme’s balance of domestic and outdoor skills shifted.
- How members from different classes and backgrounds experienced the same programme.
On the timeline
People, objects and practices
-
1912 (May, according to secondary accounts)
How Girls Can Help to Build Up the Empire (1912)
The first Guide handbook, by Agnes Baden-Powell in collaboration with her brother Robert, published by Thomas Nelson in 1912. Even its exact title wording is still to be checked against a copy.
-
1990 (September, according to an enthusiast history)
The Jeff Banks uniform range, 1990
A mix-and-match uniform range by the fashion designer Jeff Banks, launched in 1990 and first shown on the BBC's Clothes Show.
-
1930s
Guide uniform, 1930s
A navy-blue cotton shirt dress and leather belt worn by a Girl Guide between the wars, now in the V&A.
-
16 December 1858 – 2 June 1945
Agnes Baden-Powell
Organiser, first President and main author of the first Guide handbook, and a founder whom later memory largely forgot.
-
22 February 1857 – 8 January 1941
Robert Baden-Powell
Army officer and founder of Scouting, who set out the girls' scheme with his sister Agnes, wrote Guiding's handbooks from 1918 and signed them as "Founder".
-
Practice
The patrol system
Small groups led by girls themselves: Guiding's everyday training in leadership, borrowed from Scouting and made its own.
-
Essay
Badges, uniforms and handbooks
What Guides wore, earned and read, and what those objects can and cannot tell us about the girls who used them.
-
Essay
Girls who would not wait
How Guiding began, 1908–1920: girls who called themselves Scouts, the adults who gave them a scheme of their own, and the argument about what girls should do.
-
Essay
War and service
In two world wars Guides grew food, raised money, carried messages and, after 1945, worked in relief camps across Europe and beyond. How much did girls actually do, and how do we know?
Sources
- Tammy M. Proctor, “On My Honour: Guides and Scouts in Interwar Britain”, Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 92, pt 2, American Philosophical Society, 2002.
- Sarah Mills, “Scouting for girls? Gender and the Scout Movement in Britain”, Gender, Place & Culture 18, no. 4, 2011, pp. 537–556.
- Kristine Alexander, Guiding Modern Girls: Girlhood, Empire, and Internationalism in the 1920s and 1930s, UBC Press, 2017.
- Penny Tinkler, “English Girls and the International Dimensions of British Citizenship in the 1940s”, European Journal of Women's Studies 8, no. 1, 2001, pp. 103–126.
- Jim Gledhill, “White Heat, Guide Blue: The Girl Guide Movement in the 1960s”, Contemporary British History 27, no. 1, 2013, pp. 65–84.
- Amy Halls, Emma Uprichard and Clare Jackson, “Changing girlhoods – Changing Girl Guiding”, The Sociological Review 66, no. 1, 2018, pp. 257–272.